"Henry Johnson is David Mamet’s first theatrical feature in 18 years. The Pulitzer-winning playwright-turned-filmmaker has since been an outspoken proponent of what he calls “the tragic view,” the idea that man is sinful, life is complicated, and when faced with moral choices, we are often obliged to choose between two evils. "

"All the world’s a con to David Mamet, and if that viewpoint has long characterized his work—resulting in at least two masterpieces, Glengarry Glen Ross and American Buffalo—it continues to feel fresh in Henry Johnson."

"The abyss stares back––that’s the overwhelming feeling of David Mamet’s new film Henry Johnson. It’s based on his play of the same name from 2023, and with both that date and Mamet’s recent public persona, one would probably have some assumptions about this story’s political bent. Watching the film, you’re reminded that we can come to some kind of mutual understanding with those on the other side. "

"...the actors assembled for Henry Johnson showcase their adept and nimble skills at following the ideas here, which is not easy. All of them are top-notch, and if the industry actually awarded deserving performances instead of the consensus of the flavor of the month, Henry Johnson would be an SAG ensemble nominee."

"At a time when the world seems increasingly divided into winners and losers, exploiters and suckers, Henry Johnson speaks with sardonic eloquence to our current moment in American life."

"Mamet at the peak of his considerable powers… Shia LaBeouf and Evan Jonigkeit are riveting."